Why should practice essays be reviewed by a peer or mentor?

Gaining feedback on structure and clarity is crucial when reviewing practice essays, as these elements are foundational to effective writing. A peer or mentor can provide an outside perspective that helps identify areas where the argument may be unclear, where transitions could be smoother, or where the overall organization could be improved. Their insights can enhance the flow of ideas, ensuring that the essay communicates its message effectively and engagingly. This collaborative feedback process fosters a deeper understanding of writing conventions and can lead to improved writing skills over time.

In contrast, ensuring that essays are "not overly complex" addresses a different concern, but doesn't fully capture the broader benefits of peer feedback. Eliminating the need for revisions misunderstands the iterative nature of writing, where revisions are often essential for polishing and improving work. While minimizing writing time might seem advantageous, it overlooks the importance of thoroughness and reflection in the writing process, which typically involves thoughtful revisions and feedback.